Serious criminality, in subsection 36(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, can be found against a permanent resident or a foreign national, and it turns on a maximum penalty of ten years or more, or on a Canadian sentence of more than six months. Criminality, in subsection 36(2), can be found against foreign nationals only, and it turns on whether the offence can be prosecuted by indictment, or on two offences that did not come out of the same event.
The label keeps working long after the finding. It decides who makes the removal order, whether the Immigration Appeal Division can hear an appeal, and whether a refugee claim can go forward. Angelina Shuster is a paralegal licensed by the Law Society of Ontario, and the Immigration Division and the Immigration Appeal Division are tribunals of the Immigration and Refugee Board where licensed paralegals represent people. This article is general information about the Act as it reads on 18 November 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create a paralegal-client relationship.
Which part of section 36 can reach which person?
Status is the first filter. Subsection 36(2) opens with the words "A foreign national is inadmissible", so a permanent resident can only be caught by the serious branch.
Permanent resident
- A conviction in Canada, under paragraph 36(1)(a).
- A conviction in another country, under 36(1)(b).
- An act abroad with no conviction at all, under 36(1)(c). For a permanent resident, 36(3)(d) requires that act to be shown on a balance of probabilities.
Foreign national
- Everything in the left column, read the same way.
- Under 36(2)(a), a Canadian conviction for an indictable offence, or two federal convictions from separate events.
- Under 36(2)(b), those same two tests applied to convictions abroad.
- Under 36(2)(c), an act abroad that would be indictable here.
- Under 36(2.1), transborder criminality: a prescribed offence committed while entering Canada.
For a permanent resident, a record that only meets the criminality tests sits outside section 36 entirely. For anyone whose offence happened in another country, the first job is to find its Canadian counterpart, a comparison explained in how a foreign conviction is equivalenced. The rest of this article follows convictions entered by a Canadian court, where no comparison is needed.
How is a conviction from a Canadian court sorted?
By a short run of questions, asked in this order. Each answer either ends the inquiry or sends it to the next line.
- Is there a record suspension in force for this conviction, or a final acquittal?If yes: section 36 cannot rest on it Paragraph 36(3)(b).
- Was the offence under a federal Act, and not a Contraventions Act ticket or a youth sentence?If no: section 36 cannot rest on it The section speaks of an Act of Parliament, so a conviction under a provincial statute such as the Highway Traffic Act is not counted. Paragraph 36(3)(e) removes the other two.
- Does the offence carry a maximum term of imprisonment of at least ten years?If yes: serious criminality, 36(1)(a) The sentence actually given does not matter on this branch. A fine is enough.
- Was a term of imprisonment of more than six months imposed for it?If yes: serious criminality, 36(1)(a) Exactly six months does not cross this line. More than six months does.
- Is the person a permanent resident?If yes: the inquiry under section 36 ends here The remaining questions apply to foreign nationals only.
- Could the offence have been prosecuted by indictment, including a hybrid offence the Crown took summarily?If yes: criminality, 36(2)(a) Paragraph 36(3)(a) treats every hybrid offence as indictable for this purpose.
- Is there a second federal conviction that arose from a different occurrence?If yes: criminality, 36(2)(a) If no: neither label applies
Why can a minor charge still lead to criminality?
Two rules in the section reach well below the ten-year line, and both apply only to foreign nationals.
The hybrid rule
Many offences in the Criminal Code are hybrid: the Crown chooses whether to proceed summarily or by indictment. Assault under section 266 is one. Its maximum, when it goes by indictment, is five years, so a conviction for it is not serious criminality unless the sentence passed six months. For a foreign national, though, paragraph 36(3)(a) deems the offence indictable even when the Crown chose the summary route and the court imposed a fine. The conviction then meets 36(2)(a). The difference between the two routes, and who chooses, is set out in what a summary offence means in Canada.
The two-offence rule
Two convictions for offences that are summary only, the lowest tier of federal offence, also meet 36(2)(a), provided they did not arise out of a single occurrence. The words point to the event, not to the number of charges: two convictions that come out of one incident share a single occurrence, while the same two offences committed months apart in unrelated events do not. The Act does not count provincial offences toward the pair, because both convictions must be under an Act of Parliament.
What does each label change after the finding?
Most of the consequences sit outside section 36, in the sections on removal orders, appeals and refugee protection. Read side by side, they show why officers, tribunal members and counsel look at the label so closely.
| Point | Criminality, s. 36(2) | Serious criminality, s. 36(1) |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides on a conviction in Canada | For a foreign national whose report rests only on 36(2)(a), the Minister's delegate generally makes a deportation order, subject to the exceptions in the same section. There is no hearing at the Immigration Division (IRPR s. 228(1)(a)). | The same for a foreign national under 36(1)(a). For a permanent resident, the report is referred to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing (IRPA s. 44(2)). |
| Appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division | Section 64 does not bar it. Whether an appeal exists then depends on who the person is under section 63. | Barred where the crime was punished in Canada by imprisonment of at least six months, or where the finding rests on 36(1)(b) or (c) (s. 64(2)). |
| A refugee claim not yet referred to the Board | Not made ineligible by this ground. | Ineligible only where the person has been found inadmissible and the conviction carries a maximum of at least ten years (s. 101(1)(f) and (2)). |
| Refugee protection through a PRRA | Not restricted by this ground. | Cannot be conferred where the finding rests on a conviction carrying a maximum of at least ten years (s. 112(3)(b)). |
| A stay of removal already granted by the IAD | Cancelled by law, and the appeal ended, if the person is later convicted of an offence referred to in 36(1) (s. 68(4)). | The same rule applies. |
The appeal row hides a gap that surprises people. A conviction in Canada for an offence with a ten-year maximum is serious criminality even when the sentence was a fine or a short jail term. Section 64(2), though, only takes away the appeal where the crime was punished by at least six months of imprisonment. A permanent resident in that position is inadmissible for serious criminality and still keeps a right of appeal. Who holds that right in the first place is covered in who can appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division.
The refugee rows work the same way. A sentence of more than six months on an offence with a lower maximum makes a person inadmissible for serious criminality, yet sections 101(2) and 112(3)(b) look only at the ten-year maximum. In that situation, this ground on its own does not stop the claim from being referred to the Refugee Protection Division.
What can section 36 never be based on?
Subsection 36(3) sets out the records that cannot support either label, whatever the offence was.
- A conviction covered by a record suspension that has not been revoked and has not ceased to have effect under the Criminal Records Act.
- A charge that ended in a final determination of acquittal.
- An offence designated as a contravention under the Contraventions Act.
- A finding of guilt under the old Young Offenders Act, or a youth sentence under the Youth Criminal Justice Act.
A record suspension is the one item on that list a person can apply for. The Parole Board of Canada decides it, and the application is described on the page about record suspension applications.
Where does rehabilitation fit?
Only on the foreign side. Paragraph 36(3)(c) lets rehabilitation remove paragraphs 36(1)(b) and (c) and 36(2)(b) and (c), the ones about offences abroad. It does not mention 36(1)(a) or 36(2)(a), so a Canadian conviction is not cured this way.
There are two forms. One is an application in which the Minister must be satisfied that the person has been rehabilitated after the prescribed period. The other happens by the passage of time, under section 18 of the Regulations. The first branch of that section covers one foreign offence equivalent to an indictable offence with a maximum of less than ten years, once ten years have passed since the sentence was completed and the other conditions are met. The second covers two or more offences equivalent to summary offences, after five years. Neither branch covers an offence with a ten-year maximum, so deemed rehabilitation never touches serious criminality. The two routes are compared in deemed rehabilitation and criminal rehabilitation.
Where a paralegal works on these files
When a report reaches the Immigration Division, the hearing turns on whether the record meets the paragraph the Minister relies on: the maximum penalty on the date of the offence, the sentence actually imposed, whether two convictions came from one event, and whether anything in subsection 36(3) applies. That is the work of admissibility hearings before the Immigration Division, and of appeals to the IAD where section 64 leaves one open. A person who wants a reading of where a record falls can request a free assessment.



